Close Menu
    Facebook Instagram LinkedIn
    • العربية (Arabic)
    • English
    • Français (French)
    Facebook Instagram LinkedIn
    Middle East Transparent
    • Home
    • Categories
      1. Headlines
      2. Features
      3. Commentary
      4. Magazine
      Featured
      Headlines Itai Melchior and Nir Boms

      Why al-Sharaa’s success in Syria is good for Israel and the US

      Recent
      3 July 2025

      Why al-Sharaa’s success in Syria is good for Israel and the US

      27 June 2025

      The Poisoned Chalice: President Trump’s Opportunity with Iran

      26 June 2025

      Post-Attack Assessment of the First 12 Days of Israeli and U.S. Strikes on Iranian Nuclear Facilities

    • Contact us
    • Archives
    • Subscribe
    • العربية (Arabic)
    • English
    • Français (French)
    Middle East Transparent
    You are at:Home»Categories»Commentary»Zealots Should Not Oversee Holy Sites

    Zealots Should Not Oversee Holy Sites

    0
    By Salman Masalha on 29 October 2015 Commentary

    Only objective secularists can safeguard the holiness attributed to these sites, to preserve the holiness of humankind, and prevent bloodshed.

    As time passes, and the tribal, jingoistic tension rises, it is beginning to influence not only the opinions of Jews and Palestinians, but also their religious beliefs. Nationalism and tribalism, with a dose of religious fervor, is a toxic mix, which can incite blood-thirstiness and a desire for revenge.

    At the memorial service commemorating the two-year anniversary of Rabbi Ovadia Yosef’s death, Israeli Chief Rabbi Yitzhak Yosef, called on Jews to stop ascending to the Temple Mount. “All the great rabbis, dozens upon dozens, have written that it’s forbidden to go up to the Temple Mount,” said Yosef, and attacked those who do visit there, noting “some believe nationalism takes priority over halakha.” Meaning, for some Jews who do go up to the Mount, nationalism has trumped their religious beliefs.

    But not only are Jewish religious beliefs succumbing to nationalism. Here’s a quote from the October 8 edition of the Al-Hayat newspaper: “There are no Jewish archaeological artifacts in Palestine, no Temple, no first, nor second, nor tenth. There are no prophets or kingdoms, no Jewish kings in Palestine or anywhere else.”

    This nonsense was written by Jihad Al Khazen, a senior Palestinian journalist, a hack, serving all Arab rulers, but particularly the Saudi kingdom. He often publishes such nonsense in his columns in the newspaper (which is widely read throughout the Arab world).

    The remarks sound even more outrageous and unfounded as they’re written by a Christian journalist, who thus burns the bridges behind him — as his remarks deny the existence of Jesus, who was a Jew. The Gospel according to Matthew reads: “When Jesus entered Jerusalem, the whole city was stirred and asked, ‘who is this?’ The crowds answered, ‘this is Jesus, the prophet from Nazareth in Galilee. Jesus entered the temple courts and drove out all who were buying and selling there… he said to them, ‘my house will be called a house of prayer.’”

    Tribal nationalism is trumping faith even among Islamists. The Muslim tradition never denied the holiness of the Temple Mount — with the foundation stone at its center — to Judaism and the Jews. In one hadith, or statement attributed to the Prophet Mohammed in the Koran, and quoted both in Sunni and Shi’ite sources, the prophet waits for God to command him to change the Qibla, or direction that Muslims face during prayer, from Jerusalem to Mecca, or more accurately from the Temple stone to the black stone and the Kaaba. This is because Jerusalem is the “Jewish Qibla,” according to one 8th century koranic commentary.

    This perception regarding the stone was common for Muslims throughout history. Take, for example, Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyya, the 13th century Muslim scholar, who wrote, “the holiest thing about the stone is that it is the Qibla of the Jews.” Sayyid Qutb, the father of the Muslim Brotherhood, also held this opinion in modern times. “Bait Almiqdas [Arabic for the Temple] is the Qibla for the Jews, and their place of prayer,” wrote Qutb in the 1950’s.

    The logical conclusion is that religion, any religion, and specifically monotheism, is too dangerous to be left in the hands of zealots and fools. Religious rule in a multi-religious society is likely to destroy everything.

    Thus jurisdiction over holy sites must remain with objective secularists. Only they can safeguard the holiness attributed to these sites, to preserve the holiness of humankind, and prevent bloodshed.
    *
    Haaretz, October 27, 2015

    *
    For Hebrew, press here

    For Arabic, press here

    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email WhatsApp Copy Link
    Previous ArticleTurkey needs to ‘upgrade’ its democracy, says former president
    Next Article Russia Stumbles in Syrian Air War
    Subscribe
    Notify of
    guest

    guest

    0 Comments
    Newest
    Oldest Most Voted
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    RSS Recent post in french
    • Ce que nous attendons de vous, Monsieur le Président 3 July 2025 Michel Hajji Georgiou
    • Il faut être pour Nétanyahou lorsqu’il affaiblit la menace iranienne ; et ardemment contre lui lorsqu’il détruit Gaza 1 July 2025 Denis Charbit
    • En Syrie, la mystérieuse disparition du corps de Hafez el-Assad 11 June 2025 Apolline Convain
    • En Syrie, après les massacres d’alaouites, la difficulté de recueillir des témoignages : « Je n’ai pas confiance » 5 June 2025 Madjid Zerrouky
    • Guerre en Ukraine : Kiev démontre sa force de frappe en bombardant l’aviation russe avec ses drones, jusqu’en Sibérie 2 June 2025 Le Monde
    RSS Recent post in arabic
    • الاستدعاءات في لبنان: عودة “الروح العضومية” 4 July 2025 عمر حرقوص
    • ماذا يجري في مرفأ بيروت؟ 4 July 2025 خاص بالشفاف
    • دراسة استطلاعية: أحمد الصراف الكاتب الأكثر قراءة وتأثيراً في الكويت 3 July 2025 الشفّاف
    • والدة قائد بـ”الحرس” قتلته إسرائيل: إبني شارك في “تفخيخ” احتفالات الحكم البهلوي 3 July 2025 شفاف- خاص
    • ملف كازينو لبنان: توقيف رئيس مجلس الإدارة رولان الخوري؟ 2 July 2025 المدن
    26 February 2011

    Metransparent Preliminary Black List of Qaddafi’s Financial Aides Outside Libya

    6 December 2008

    Interview with Prof Hafiz Mohammad Saeed

    7 July 2009

    The messy state of the Hindu temples in Pakistan

    27 July 2009

    Sayed Mahmoud El Qemany Apeal to the World Conscience

    8 March 2022

    Russian Orthodox priests call for immediate end to war in Ukraine

    Recent Comments
    • Edward Ziadeh on Why al-Sharaa’s success in Syria is good for Israel and the US
    • Giant Squirrel on Holier Than Thou: Politics and the Pulpit in America
    • Edward Ziadeh on As Church awaits a Conclave, President Trump puts up picture of himself as next Pope
    • Victoria Perea on As Church awaits a Conclave, President Trump puts up picture of himself as next Pope
    • Victoria Perea on As Church awaits a Conclave, President Trump puts up picture of himself as next Pope
    Donate
    Donate
    © 2025 Middle East Transparent

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    loader

    Inscrivez-vous à la newsletter

    En vous inscrivant, vous acceptez nos conditions et notre politique de confidentialité.

    loader

    Subscribe to updates

    By signing up, you agree to our terms privacy policy agreement.

    loader

    اشترك في التحديثات

    بالتسجيل، فإنك توافق على شروطنا واتفاقية سياسة الخصوصية الخاصة بنا.

    wpDiscuz