Close Menu
    Facebook Instagram LinkedIn
    • العربية (Arabic)
    • English
    • Français (French)
    Facebook Instagram LinkedIn
    Middle East Transparent
    • Home
    • Categories
      1. Headlines
      2. Features
      3. Commentary
      4. Magazine
      Featured
      Headlines POLITICO

      Leo is America’s first pope. His worldview appears at odds with ‘America First.’

      Recent
      11 May 2025

      Leo is America’s first pope. His worldview appears at odds with ‘America First.’

      5 May 2025

      Most U.S. Catholics Say They Want the Church To Be ‘More Inclusive’

      4 May 2025

      As Church awaits a Conclave, President Trump puts up picture of himself as next Pope

    • Contact us
    • Archives
    • Subscribe
    • العربية (Arabic)
    • English
    • Français (French)
    Middle East Transparent
    You are at:Home»Categories»Headlines»Papal diplomacy in Syria has helped Russia and Assad

    Papal diplomacy in Syria has helped Russia and Assad

    0
    By Crux on 16 March 2017 Headlines

    The President of Syria, Bashar al-Assad, reads a letter by Pope Francis given to him by Cardinal Mario Zenari, Apostolic Nuncio to Syria. (Credit: Syrian Arab News Agency.)

     

    Father Raymond J. De Souza

    SPECIAL TO CRUX

     

    The anniversary week of Pope Francis has prompted many commentators to list the highlights of the pontificate. The pope’s foreign policy – especially in Syria – should not be added to these lists. Vatican diplomacy has resulted in Assad being more secure in Damascus, with his staunch ally Putin playing a greater role in the Middle East.
     The anniversary week of Pope Francis has prompted many of us commentators to list the highlights of the pontificate. For my part I highlighted the Jubilee of Mercy and the emphasis on corporal works of mercy, exemplified by the revitalization of the role of papal almoner.

    My colleague, John Allen, listed various “clear wins” under which he included the pope’s foreign policy. That struck me as curious, because it seems that what in the Vatican parlance is called “relations with states” is one of the weak points of the Franciscan pontificate.

    Pope Francis has devoted particular attention to four countries – Syria, Ukraine, Cuba and Venezuela. It is hard to see how the ordinary people of any of those countries, to say nothing of the Catholic population, is better off for those interventions.

    Is Pope Francis responsible for the human disasters in those countries? Obviously not. But they can hardly be characterized as success stories of papal diplomacy – even Cuba, which is the one most trumpeted as such. But that’s a separate case. Syria bears examination, about which Allen wrote:

    In September 2013 [Pope Francis] led the moral charge against a proposed Western military intervention in Syria following charges that Bashar al-Assad had deployed chemical weapons against opposition-controlled areas around Damascus. Francis launched an all-out diplomatic push against widening the conflict, and was later credited by Russian President Vladimir Putin with being decisive in halting the momentum with the G8 towards supporting the initiative.

    Having Putin credit you with stopping Western action would seem to be grounds for criticism, not compliment. In September 2013, Pope Francis was at the height of his global popularity. His “Who am I to judge?” airborne press conference earned him exultant praise from the global lifestyle left. Doctrinal controversies within the Church were still in the future.

    He invested his full stature in opposing possible American-led strikes to enforce President Barack Obama’s red line against the use of chemical weapons. He called for Catholics the world over to join his St. Peter’s prayer vigil against Western military action.

    Had Obama been determined to enforce his policy, Francis could not have stopped him. Yet the papal diplomatic effort did have its effect, and the Syrian situation was resolved with Assad having to hand over his chemical weapons to the United Nations, where he could count on Russia’s Security Council veto to protect him. The Russians would also be the guarantor of Assad’s compliance, meaning that one ally was monitoring the other.

    The Obama collapse – widely considered the greatest failure of his foreign policy – established Russia as the principal foreign power in Syria. Putin badly outmaneuvered Obama, and while Francis did not put the Vatican on Putin’s side, in opposing Western action he advanced a resolution that favored the interests of both Assad and Putin.

    After Assad’s use of chemical weapons, the Obama-Francis diplomacy resulted in Assad more secure in Damascus, with his staunch ally Putin playing a greater role in the Middle East than Russia had played since Anwar Sadat threw the Soviets out of Egypt in 1972.

    Neither pope nor president regarded their efforts in Syria as a massive failure at the time, but Putin certainly regarded it as a major victory. He immediately began to flex Moscow’s muscles in Ukraine, directing his ally there to abandon a proposed agreement with the European Union in favor of an alliance with Russia and Belarus.

    The ensuing Ukrainian popular uprising challenged Putin’s plans, but he had to wait until after the Sochi Olympics in 2014 to act. The Olympic torch was hardly extinguished before Russian troops were on the move, invading and swallowing up Crimea. There was no Obama red line this time. There was no papal prayer vigil.

    Putin, having calculated that between Obama and Francis he would face neither significant material nor moral opposition, would move from strength to strength. Russian troops would invade eastern Ukraine and occupy it. In time, he and his ally Assad would cement their control of what was left of Syria with the brutal razing of Aleppo.

    The irony is even more cruel when one considers that the post-2013 Syrian refugee crisis that has so destabilized Europe is another result of the strengthening of Assad and Putin. Pope Francis has been insistent on the obligation to receive refugees; he has been less vocal on the causes that drive refugees from their homes. The millions of Syrian refugees are the result of Assad’s civil war and ineffective international action. Papal diplomacy was on the side of what turned out to be ineffective international action.

    Papal diplomacy subsequently resorted to offering gestures – powerful gestures, but gestures – that seek to comfort the afflicted who can expect no practical assistance from the international community. Pope Francis made the nuncio in Syria a cardinal and had him deliver a letter to Assad, asking him to stop massacring his opponents. The Vatican organized a collection in Europe to support Ukrainians suffering from Russian aggression. Gestures are what remain when policy fails.

    Perhaps there was nothing that the Holy See could have done that would have impeded the march of Putin once Obama abandoned the field. Yet it remains that the papal intervention did make it more difficult for Obama to enforce his policy, had he wanted to.

    The global pressure brought to bear by Pope Francis favored the villains, even if that was clearly not the intention. That is little comfort to the suffering. Naïveté in the relations with states is costly, even if well intentioned. It was not a “clear win” for Pope Francis, and much less so for the Syrian people.

    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email WhatsApp Copy Link
    Previous ArticleI will even miss my enemies, says retired general Amos Gilad
    Next Article Will Lebanon put off parliamentary elections again?
    Subscribe
    Notify of
    guest

    guest

    0 Comments
    Newest
    Oldest Most Voted
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    RSS Recent post in french
    • Al-Charaa en visite à Paris : « Les Européens se laissent berner parce qu’ils prennent leurs rêves pour des réalités » 8 May 2025 Hughes Maillot
    • Au Yémen, la surprenante résilience des rebelles houthistes 6 May 2025 Georges Malbrunot
    • Walid Joumblatt, chef politique des Druzes du Liban : « Le pire des scénarios serait que les Druzes syriens soient poussés dans une enclave » 5 May 2025 Laure Stephan
    • Robert Ageneau, théologien : « Il est urgent de réformer, voire d’abolir, la papauté » 4 May 2025 Le Monde
    • Trump veut un pape à son image 3 May 2025 François Clemenceau
    RSS Recent post in arabic
    • رامي مخلوف يُعلن تشكيل “ميليشيا” خاصة للدفاع عن “الطائفة” 10 May 2025 سويس أنفو
    • وجهة النظر المضادة: الشرع راديكالي يتظاهر بالإعتدال، والأوروبيون يخلطون أحلامهم بالواقع 8 May 2025 خاص بالشفاف
    • في اليمن: الصمود المفاجئ للمتمرّدين الحوثيين 6 May 2025 جورج مالبرونو
    • ليس هناك وقت أفضل لنزع سلاح “حزب الله” 5 May 2025 ديفيد شينكر
    • “البابا ترامب” مزحة أم محاولة لوضع اليد على الكاثوليكية؟ 5 May 2025 بيار عقل
    26 February 2011

    Metransparent Preliminary Black List of Qaddafi’s Financial Aides Outside Libya

    6 December 2008

    Interview with Prof Hafiz Mohammad Saeed

    7 July 2009

    The messy state of the Hindu temples in Pakistan

    27 July 2009

    Sayed Mahmoud El Qemany Apeal to the World Conscience

    8 March 2022

    Russian Orthodox priests call for immediate end to war in Ukraine

    Recent Comments
    • Edward Ziadeh on As Church awaits a Conclave, President Trump puts up picture of himself as next Pope
    • Victoria Perea on As Church awaits a Conclave, President Trump puts up picture of himself as next Pope
    • Victoria Perea on As Church awaits a Conclave, President Trump puts up picture of himself as next Pope
    • M sam on Kuwait: The Gulf state purging tens of thousands of its citizens
    • Aadam Peer on How important is the Dome of the Rock in Islam?
    Donate
    Donate
    © 2025 Middle East Transparent

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    wpDiscuz
    loader

    Inscrivez-vous à la newsletter

    En vous inscrivant, vous acceptez nos conditions et notre politique de confidentialité.

    loader

    Subscribe to updates

    By signing up, you agree to our terms privacy policy agreement.

    loader

    اشترك في التحديثات

    بالتسجيل، فإنك توافق على شروطنا واتفاقية سياسة الخصوصية الخاصة بنا.